Document describes crime scene 
2001-02-28 
By Ken Raymond 
The Daily Oklahoman 
Staff Writer 
 
A bloody crime scene, a rumored affair and apparently inappropriate emotional responses led police to arrest Dr. 
John Baxter Hamilton hours 
after his wife was slain in the 
couple's Quail Creek home, police said in an affidavit released Tuesday.
  
- 
Probable cause affidavit 
- 
Search warrant affidavit 
Requires:
Adobe Acrobat  
Dr. Hamilton 911 call:
Real Audio |
Transcript 
 
The document -- a probable 
cause affidavit signed by an Oklahoma County 
District Court 
judge -- describes some of 
the evidence 
that led homicide detectives 
to believe Hamilton beat and 
strangled his 
wife, Susan 
Hamilton, 55.  
Mack Martin, 
Hamilton's attorney, has said 
his client is not 
guilty of the crime. Martin declined to comment Tuesday.  
Hamilton, a prominent obstetrician and gynecologist, was 
charged with first-degree murder. He has been held without 
bail in the Oklahoma County 
jail since Feb. 14, the day of the 
slaying.  
Hamilton, 52, called 911 at 
11:06 a.m. on Valentine's Day, 
telling dispatchers that somebody "hurt" his wife, who was 
"bleeding all over the place." He 
identified himself as a doctor 
and said he thought his wife 
was dead.  
When police arrived, Hamilton was wearing bloodstained 
clothing, but no shoes or necktie. His wife was lying nude on 
the bathroom floor in a pool of 
blood. She had suffered blunt-
force trauma to her forehead, 
and a necktie was around her 
neck.  
The doctor told police he performed cardiopulmonary resuscitation on his wife, then called for 
help when she did not respond, 
the affidavit says. He resumed 
CPR after completing the call. 
Hamilton was taken to police 
headquarters for questioning.  
Police described his demeanor as inappropriate.  
"Dr. Hamilton appeared to be 
acting and not truly concerned 
for the victim," the document 
said. "Dr. Hamilton did not act 
as a person who often comes in 
contact with emergency situations."  
From talking to those who 
knew the couple, police learned 
that Susan Hamilton recently 
had accused her husband of 
having an affair, which led to 
"heated" arguments, the affidavit says.  
The condition of the crime 
scene also made investigators 
suspicious, the affidavit said.  
"Although the house was reported unlocked and opened by 
Dr. Hamilton, there was no evidence of escape by a bloody suspect," the affidavit said. "The 
crime scene was extremely 
bloody, and the suspect could 
not have left the residence without leaving some evidence of a 
blood trail."  
Hamilton was arrested about 
six hours after he called for 
help.  
A separate affidavit made 
available Monday lists physical 
evidence -- including clothing, 
a bloody wash rag, Valentine's 
Day cards, syringes and thousands of dollars in cash -- that 
were taken from Hamilton's 
house, automobile and locker in 
the men's surgical dressing 
room at Mercy Health Center.  
  |